#1
Simma's Bakery
★ 4.7(1369)
Wauwatosa, WI
Established, family-owned bakeshop whipping up cakes, cheesecakes & pastries in casual digs.
Milwaukee · 2026
The best wedding bakeries in Milwaukee, WI
11 vetted wedding bakeries serving Milwaukee and the surrounding area. Ranked by verified reviews, response time, and track record.
11
Bakeries listed
4.6 / 5
Average rating
5,230
Verified reviews analyzed
9%
Rated 4.8 or higher
Source: the All Wedding directory dataset for Milwaukee, WI, updated July 2026.
Top-ranked bakeries in Milwaukee, WI
#2
Grebe's Bakery
★ 4.6(1470)
West Allis, WI
Family-owned bakery/deli since 1937 offering homemade desserts & American breakfast & lunch staples.
#3
Aggie's Bakery & Cake Shop
★ 4.6(1429)
West Allis, WI
Charming standby offering baked goods ranging from donuts to special-occasion cakes, plus espresso.
#4
Midwest Sad
★ 4.9(168)
Milwaukee, WI
Services: Outdoor seating, Onsite services, Takeout, Dine-in.
#5
C. Adam's Bakery
★ 4.4(276)
Milwaukee, WI
Services: Onsite services, Takeout.
#6
Greige Pâtisserie
★ 4.7(166)
Milwaukee, WI
Services: Onsite services, Takeout, Dine-in.
#7
Black Twig Bakery
★ 4.7(109)
Wauwatosa, WI
Services: In-store pickup, In-store shopping, Onsite services, Takeout.
#8
Elevate Coffee & Piece of Love
★ 4.6(105)
West Allis, WI
Services: No-contact delivery, Delivery, Onsite services, Takeout, Dine-in.
#9
Cake and Bake
★ 4.7(91)
Menomonee Falls, WI
Bakery selling cupcakes, pastries & custom wedding cakes, plus baking & decorating classes.
#10
Whisk Chick
★ 4.2(34)
Milwaukee, WI
Services: Takeout.
#11
Erica the Cake Whisperer- HOME BASED BUSINESS
★ 4.6(13)
Milwaukee, WI
Services: Takeout.
Other wedding vendors in Milwaukee
Wedding venues in Milwaukee
Find a venue that matches your guest count, budget, and the kind of day you actually want.
Wedding photographers in Milwaukee
Book someone whose work you'd frame, who ships galleries on time, and who feels right on the day.
Wedding planners in Milwaukee
Hire a planner who answers emails in 24 hours and has done a wedding like yours before.
Wedding caterers in Milwaukee
Feed your guests food they remember, from caterers with references you can actually call.
Nearby cities
Read before you book a wedding bakery
budget
How Much Does a Wedding Cake Cost in 2026?
Wedding cake pricing in 2026: $4 to $12 per slice, $500 to $1,200 for most couples. What drives cake quotes, cutting fees, and the dessert-table alternative.
4 min read
vendors
What to Ask a Wedding Baker Before the Tasting
The questions that reveal hidden costs and real capabilities before you commit to a wedding baker. Delivery logistics, allergy protocols, and the tasting-fee math.
9 min read
budget
Where to Splurge and Where to Save on a Wedding
Ranked by actual return on investment over 40 years of marriage, not industry marketing. Where extra dollars matter, and where they don't.
8 min read
Frequently asked
How much do wedding bakeries cost in Milwaukee?
Pricing varies widely by season and package. Most bakeries in Milwaukee publish starting rates on their profiles here. Peak wedding months (usually April through October) run 15-25% higher than off-season.
How do I contact a wedding bakery on this list?
Each profile has direct contact info (phone, email, website, Instagram). We don't gate the information or force you through a form.
Can wedding bakeries pay to rank higher on this page?
No. Ranking weights are published and fixed. Featured placements are clearly labeled and appear separately from the main list.